When should you use the ‘Jobs to be done’ framework?

JTBD, popularised in 2016 by Clayton Christensen, is one of the popular frameworks in the world of PMs. Like everything, it has its plusses and minuses. When do you use it, and when do you think one should avoid it?

  • Head of Product at Memrise

    I think JTBD is a great discovery tool when taking bigger swings in your product. It’s a lens to remind you and the team that your users don’t ultimately want to perform tasks or activities, but rather they want to make a change in their life situation. This mindset helps you define/ prioritise user problems and sense check the solutions that flow from them, keeping your product development efforts focused on what matters.

    JTBD can also lead you to re-evaluate some fundamental product/marketing assumptions — the value that your product brings to users, how should you categorise (segment) users, and who your competitors are — allowing you to think more holistically.

    I find JTBD to be less useful for smaller product swings that iterate on an existing feature. There are still ‘problems to solve’ with an existing feature, but the job usually hasn’t changed. Instead you tend to be helping the user to use the feature with less friction (i.e do the job slightly better). Because JTBD encourages you to think from first principles, it can sometimes feel like overkill in these situations.

    I also think that, because it’s a discovery tool, JTBD doesn’t speak to how your team and company delivers on problems/jobs. So, even if you have a great handle on discovery, the delivery side still needs to be there for you to delight your users and make a great product.

    Ask Kevin a follow-up question!

    Ask a question
  • Founder at Active Pathways

    JTBD offers new lenses to approach a product challenge.

    Instead of finding this answer to this question: "How our solution solves this particular problem?", we should ask two JTBD questions:

    • Which (universal) JOB (emotional/functional) is the user hiring your product for?
    • Why should they switch to your solution?

    Exploring those two answers will give you a completely new perspective of your real competition and an opportunity to create innovative solutions.

    Ask Javier a follow-up question!

    Ask a question
  • Head of Product at Showtime Analytics

    My team uses JTBD before we start the design of any feature. We use JTBD to start the conversation about whether we have enough context about the problem before investigating a solution.
    We don't use JTBD when it relates to something that is necessary to make another thing work, for e.g. buying email credits to send emails.

    Ask Ian a follow-up question!

    Ask a question
  • PM at CommerceHub

    JTBD is one of the best ways to learn about what the experience is like for your target customer, in the moment that they use your product (or an alternative solution).

    The framework provides a way to evaluate the "forces of progress" that hinder the customer from taking action to make progress on what they are trying to accomplish. The more you can understand what is happening in the moment the customer is struggling to make progress, the better you can cater your solution to address the root of their problem.

    Ask Mallory a follow-up question!

    Ask a question
  • The Team at JAM

    JTBD. There are many people whose eyes will light up when you mention this acronym. There are also many who will rather roll them. The best approach probably lies in the middle (what would that be in eyes’ terms? Squinting?)

    In a nutshell, “jobs to be done” is a way of looking at a product through identifying reasons why customers buy it. It’s answering the question: What jobs are people recruiting my product for?

    All PMs know it’s crucial to establish a problem a product is solving before building it. That’s a top level understanding: You’ll need to find a problem, and define the people who have it (these will be your users FYI!).

    This is will tell you what you think you’ll be building and is the first stage of product development. The second stage, is JTBD— finding reasons why users “hire” your product.

    What is JTBD good for?

    JTBD lets you explore all functions the product. It reminds you who really owns what you're building. It’s the users, not you.

    Understanding the extra ‘jobs’ the product is performing will help you in several ways.

    • New insight into user feedback. “Your water bottle doesn’t match my yoga mat.”— you might dismiss this piece of feedback as unimportant. But, if you interpret it via the JTBD framework, you might notice something else. As much as the water bottle serves its primary function (a liquid container), for this customer it's also a symbol of social status.
    • Direction of the product. It can help remain flexible in your approach. The (sometimes) unexpected extra jobs your product is performing can highlight a better niche for the business to move into.
    • Marketing. Understanding the emotional function of the product informs the shape of your marketing campaign. It turned out your hedgehog paper holder signals openness to experience? Then, your facebook ads should target people interested in skydiving and cave exploration.

    How to act?

    One place where you need to make sure to incorporate JTBD is feedback collection. Focus on understanding the circumstances of when people use your product.

    Tip. Incorporate a version of the following question into your customer interview. Imagine [insert product] disappears from your life.

    • What changes in your life?
    • How do you feel?
    • How do you perform [action that the product is helping to perform]?

    This kind of research can reveal you're in a different business than you envisioned. Perhaps through matching a water bottle to a yoga mat you help your customer create a sense of belonging and balance the root chakra? You’re then in a business of chakras not water bottles.

    Ask JAM a follow-up question!

    Ask a question

Post your tip

Have something to add to this? We'd love to hear from you!

Post a tip

More tips like this...

Product Management
How do you say no?
There’s so much to build, and the CEO often has 10 new ideas a day. To safeguard your team’s focus, you need to say no. What are some of your best tips on answering to yet another feature request?
People & Teams
What's the #1 thing teams should expect from their Product Manager?
Product Mangers come in many shapes and sizes, and are all subject to varying expectations from team members as well. What matters the most to you and why?
How and where do you keep track of your users and stakeholders’ feedback?
Feedback comes at different times and from different corners. How not to lose track, and not to get overwhelmed? What to act on and what to ignore?
Product Management
How do you run a great user interview?
You're in discovery and searching for the problems you need to solve. Who do you speak to? Where do you find your potential users? And what questions do you ask to get the insights you need?